Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7? - Gabe Knuth - BrianMadden.com
Brian Madden Logo
Your independent source for desktop virtualization, consumerization, and enterprise mobility management.
Gabe Knuth's Blog

Past Articles

Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?

Written on Feb 06 2013 9,626 views, 5 comments


by Gabe Knuth

As a continuation of the management features of Windows 8 that I wrote last week, today's article is about how Office, Office 365, and SkyDrive fit into the equation. Office is obviously a huge part of business, and Office 365 is creeping into the collective consciousness. SkyDrive, which is mostly known as the cloud storage solution that isn't DropBox, Box, SugarSync, Google Drive, or ShareFile also factors into the discussion from both a consumer and enterprise perspective. 

On our podcast yesterday, we spent some time talking about how Brian has finally installed Office because even though is normal day to day activities only require Google Docs, the business requirements for Office are a pain in the neck to ignore. The two specific things that led him to install Office were the fact that we occasionally use pivot tables and Word comments in our jobs, and neither of those is supported by Google Docs. No doubt Microsoft is quite happy about this, as it forces people to use Windows to do their jobs (at least enough to buy a license).

The main underlying reason that we depend on Office, though, is that it's so ingrained into our business that we cannot live without it. No substitute has ever been good enough to make any significant inroads into the enterprise. In some ways that's great, because it means every company is speaking the same language, document-wise. In the past, all that we could really complain about was the licensing costs. Today, though, there are so many other form factors that can't run Office that it's becoming more troublesome than ever.

With the release of Surface tablets and Windows 8, Microsoft has also released a preview of Office 13. The fact that it's still not available seems to not bother them, but it is surely holding back companies looking to put the entire solution to use. Office 13 still requires Windows, but it's been changed a bit to run better on touch-based devices with the addition of "Touch Mode." Don't let this fool you, though. Touch Mode in Office 13 amounts to simply spreading the icons a bit further apart so that our fingers can hit the right one without inadvertently mashing some other function. There's no innovation like reworking of the interface to accommodate today's touch-based devices, though. I'd go so far as to argue that Office 13's touch mode isn't really much more useable than any other version of Office on a touch-based device. Furthermore, I'd be willing to bet that a talented application guru could probably tweak the UI of Office 2010 to look the same. 

So I'm not a fan of Touch Mode, but I'm not an Office hater. Rather, I want to use Office on my tablet and phone (not all the time, but it'd be nice to have), and I dearly wish that Microsoft would release a version of Office for the mobile platforms that people are actually using (iOS and Android) rather than trying to get people to use their mobile platforms in order to get Office. That's the kind of heavy-handedness that drives innovation, and Microsoft should be careful. For the time being, treat Office as you would any other desktop application with all the same pros and cons as any other Windows app would have in a touch-based environment. 

What about Office 365 and SkyDrive? There's a big push for using SkyDrive as part of Windows 8, not to mention Office 365. For the most part, we've looked past SkyDrive as a consumer solution not fit for the enterprise, but as Windows 8 proliferates we're bound to see it pop up more inside company walls. In fact, Microsoft released SkyDrive pro last year that adds centralized management to SkyDrive. In a way, it's a bit like SharePoint now, which is a good thing.

Office and Office 365 rely on both SharePoint and SkyDrive as the centralized data store for users, and this is the built-in solution that Microsoft provides for any, any, any access to data. This sounds like a great solution, but will it drive organizations to Windows 8? For the most part, the answer is "no." The reason for this is that all of these features don't require Windows 8 (and I am in no way saying they should require Windows 8, either). You can do all of this today with Windows 7, including all the management pieces I talked about in the previous article. In fact, considering everything I've written about so far, there are only two reasons that I can think of for organizations to care even one iota about Windows 8:

  • If, for some reason, they have a need for .appx applications (TileWorld, Windows Store, Metro…whatever you want to call it)
  • If they have to have offline access to their Windows applications on a tablet instead of a laptop

If either of those use cases arise, then Windows 8 is the natural conclusion, but if you have no TileWorld apps and no need for offline access to Windows apps on a tablet, there's no reason to make the switch. Companies that decide to rewrite their applications for TileWorld (such as British Telecom in the article that one of the commenters mentioned in the last article) are committing to Windows 8 on tablets, which is fine. There ARE use cases out there, but the vast majority of use cases in the enterprise today do not meet either of those two reasons, which is why we'll see a Vista-like adoption rate for Windows 8.

On top of that, there's only one time-based incentive to migrate OSes right now, and it's not because Windows 7 is expiring any time soon. Organizations are consumed with migrating from Windows XP to Windows 7, and Windows 7 doesn't reach end of life until January 2020. If you add the fact that you can do almost everything with Windows 7 that you can with Windows 8, plus the fact that you don't have to change it again until after Windows .Next is released, it's not shaping up well for worldwide enterprise adoption.

 
 




Our Books


Comments

help4ctx wrote re: Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?
on Wed, Feb 6 2013 10:39 AM Link To This Comment

".....there are only two reasons that I can think of for organizations to care even one iota about Windows 8"

I disagree. As I mentioned in a previous post, I believe that Windows 8 could be the catalyst for many Enterprises to re-evaluate the way their users interact with their applications and data. Windows 8 could be seen as an opportunity  to ditch our archaic views of how we access our data via keyboard and mouse,  using touch as a way to become more productive in the process. Touch is becoming so pervasive these days that the current generation of users will soon forget how to use a 'mechanical' keyboard and mouse !!

In this context I recall the file 'Minority Report' where Tom Cruise manipulates endless data feeds and data sources using touch screens and gestures  to quickly isolate data specific to his needs.  Windows 8 brings this a step closer to reality, we just need to think differently about how this interaction occurs.

Maybe this won't happen with Windows 8, but this platform is at least a starting point to get the ball rolling. It's a shame Microsoft didn't leave an 'official' mechanism  to enable the old Windows 7 'shell' in place of the new Windows 8 UI, this at least would have provided a migration possibility.

So, reason three for adopting Windows 8....to take advantage of a proper touch enabled, Enterprise OS which can after all be managed in exactly the same way as Windows 7.  

Footnote:  I played with a 24inch LED,  touch enabled  desktop PC at a local store the other day and got a headache after just 5 minutes standing close enough to the screen to use it effectively.  Maybe this could be a reason why touch enabled apps wouldn't be acceptable?  Only 'gestures' would enable us to stand far enough away from the screen to feel comfortable, and if you've used a Samsung TV recently with gesture support, this tech is far from prime time :-)

help4ctx wrote re: Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?
on Wed, Feb 6 2013 10:45 AM Link To This Comment

"Maybe this could be a reason why touch enabled apps wouldn't be acceptable?"

I meant this in the context of the Corporate desktop !

(Does this forum have an edit option that I'm not aware of?)

Gabe Knuth wrote re: Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?
on Wed, Feb 6 2013 11:42 AM Link To This Comment

Sorry, no edit function except for admins.

Wouldn't your use case for using Windows 8 fall into my first reason for using it? If you're deploying .appx apps, which are inherently touch-based, you'd want to use it.

I don't disagree with anything you're saying. My point is that there isn't much incentive beyond that to move in that direction, and when you look at the platform and the lack of apps there probably won't be for a while.  Microsoft's efforts to be "cool" have fallen short, as well as their efforts to recruit apps and developers.

Judging by the reviews,  the Surface Pro isn't all that spectacular, either, which hurts the cause that much more.

help4ctx wrote re: Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?
on Wed, Feb 6 2013 12:28 PM Link To This Comment

Yep, I suppose you are right, they would be .appx by default :-)

Amitabh Sinha wrote re: Why move to Windows 8 for Office 13, Office 365 and SkyDrive when you can do it all with Windows 7?
on Wed, Feb 6 2013 2:11 PM Link To This Comment

The Office 2013/Office 365 suite offers something else that is really interesting, independent of the O/S.

They have enabled the Office Suite as HTML5 apps that is available in your browser. So if you put an Office document on SharePoint/SkyDrive, and you click on it the document opens inside PowerPoint for WebApp, etc. They have also re-written their Outlook Web Application as an HTML5 app to have a native look and feel on the device.

I have been using all of this on my iPad/Mac, and they all work really well.

So as folks upgrade to SharePoint 2013 or Exchange 2013, they will automatically get these features.

The Office for WebApp suite is not available offline on ios. But its the best online option (even compared to CloudOn).

(Note: You must be logged in to post a comment.)

If you log in and nothing happens, delete your cookies from BrianMadden.com and try again. Sorry about that, but we had to make a one-time change to the cookie path when we migrated web servers.