Why My Books are Different than Others - Brian Madden - BrianMadden.com
Brian Madden Logo
Your independent source for desktop virtualization, consumerization, and enterprise mobility management.
Brian Madden's Blog

Past Articles

Why My Books are Different than Others

Written on Jan 02 2004
Filed under:
14,916 views, 6 comments


by Brian Madden

Since I publish the books that I write, I do whatever I want in terms of book features and layout. As a systems engineer, there are several things that annoyed me with "standard" computer books. Therefore, when I started publishing my own, I decided that my books would be different than most. Here's a list of the advantages that my books have over others, (in random order):
  1. Several other books contain many screenshots that are pointless other than taking up space and making the book thicker. (i.e. "Next, click the 'OK' button" with a picture of the "OK" button.)

  2. Some books are 7" or 7.5" wide, yet there are 1" or 1.5" inch margins. This extra white space is used to make the book appear fatter.

  3. Many books are written by multiple authors, with writing duties split by chapter. It is often apparent that they don't talk to each other, and parts of the book are repetitive.

  4. Many publishers have totally annoying "templates" that each chapter must fit into. Authors are forced to present their content in a certain way (for the publisher's "brand continuity," even when it doesn't make sense for the topic at hand.

  5. Other books have chapter summaries which basically retell the entire chapter. In my mind, these just take up space. If a reader doesn't remember what they just read, then they can flip back a few pages and reread a section.

  6. Some books claim to be about one topic, but then they spend pages and pages describing completely unrelated topics. For example, if I buy a Citrix book, I do NOT need a lesson in project management, RAID numbering, or what the OSI model is. While I agree that these are all important, they do not belong in a Citrix book.

  7. I think it's really annoying when an author spends an entire chapter explaining how technology is used, only to close the chapter with a case study that just "happens" to perfectly fit the exact situation outlined in the chapter. Case studies are cool, but only when they show real-world, tough situations whose solutions are not always obvious.

  8. There are several "design guides" where the author lists best practices for a product. The problem is that the author simply says "do it this way" instead of explaining the back-end logic as to why these best practices exist. It's not possible to educate the reader to every single potential situation for a design. Why not give them the knowledge to follow the thought process as to why certain design decisions are made? That way, they can apply the knowledge from the book to any situation—even one not covered in the book.

  9. Some computer books are nothing more that re-hashed product documentation. Even worse, some book authors "tow the company line," and regurgitate a vendor's product rhetoric. If the vendor says that a product's minimum requirement is a 200MHz Pentium, but real world experience suggests nothing less than a 700MHz Pentium, I better not find a book that says I can install it on a 200MHz Pentium. If product vendors get mad at the publishers, that's a good thing.

  10. The last thing I don't like about some "other" books is the writing style. Computer topics are usually really boring anyway, so computer books shouldn't be painful to read. I'm not talking about putting a totally lame joke on every other page. Instead, I'd rather see books that are written like people talk. Even though it's "technically" bad english, the phrase "the farm that server belongs to" sounds a lot more normal than "the farm to which that server belongs." No one talks like that, so why should books be written like that?

     
     




    Our Books


    Comments

    Guest wrote 24*7
    on Sun, Dec 12 2004 1:31 PM Link To This Comment
    This message was originally posted by JC on August 11, 2004
    Interesting Comments....now I need to go back and look at the three Citrix books at Borders and decide again which one to buy. I'm going to look at the white space issue closer now. However, should I wait for the 3rd edition..."there is no printed service pack" :-)
    Guest wrote Mmm, tasty!
    on Sat, Feb 5 2005 6:12 AM Link To This Comment
    Here's a man worth talking to... just makes way too much sense! I'm wading my way through the Sybex books on Windies 2k3 at the mo'. Having written Windows 2k, Windows XP, and now almost ready to write Win 2k3 svr.. I stand amazed at how similar they all are. Why don't they write a really thin upgrade booklet instead of reprinting the same scenarios and chapters over and over again?

    EG - Their chapter 7 on "Printing" in 2k3 has the following footnote..."The printing process used by Windows 2k and windows 2k3 are the same" (...but we need to sell this book to you, so we need to reprint the whole chapter that you should have studied for the previous core requirement exam... - "me")

    Hmmmm... I say, well done Brian. I'll look forward to reading your goods.
    Guest wrote The only book for the pub
    on Wed, Nov 9 2005 9:38 AM Link To This Comment
    I have to agree,

    After years of failing to read technical manuals, (falling asleep at most) the only one I have found so far has been the "Citrix Metaframe XP Advanced Technical Design Guide". It’s written so a "Normal" semi-nerd can enjoy it and has definitely been not only a reference guide over the last couple of years but also a darn good book. This geezer has definitely got it. It’s just a shame he hasn’t written more that’s all I have to say.
    Guest wrote Books not in store..
    on Sat, Jun 16 2007 3:01 AM Link To This Comment

    Hi Brian.

     Big fan of you.. i wanted your metaframe presentation server 4.5 book, but it is not in stores, how come ?

     

     

     

    Guest wrote What is your latest book
    on Fri, Aug 3 2007 6:00 AM Link To This Comment

    Hi Brian,


    I am also big fan of you.. could you please let me know what is latest edition of your book??  I am going to order but just wnaded to check with you.

    Guest wrote SOLD!
    on Sat, Sep 15 2007 10:24 PM Link To This Comment
    I'll buy your book to learn what I need about Presentation server 4.5! Oh, wait a minute. It's STILL not available. Guess I'll have to go with one of the others........

    (Note: You must be logged in to post a comment.)

    If you log in and nothing happens, delete your cookies from BrianMadden.com and try again. Sorry about that, but we had to make a one-time change to the cookie path when we migrated web servers.